This view of the exterior of St Albans Abbey, shown from a point close to the east end looking towards the great Norman crossing tower, is one of a group of images of the church and its surrounds that Girtin seems to have sketched around 1796, others including The Gateway, St Albans Abbey (TG1034) and St Albans Abbey: The West Porch (TG1035). The artist presumably visited the site to take the sort of detailed study required to produce the major watercolour view of the interior of the church that was shown at the Royal Academy in 1797 and is dated 1796 (TG1040). It is possible that this drawing was produced with a similar-scale composition in mind but this time showing an exterior view. Certainly there is enough information included in the sheet for Girtin to have produced a detailed depiction of the abbey that might have resembled one of the impressive views of Gothic buildings that he painted for his early patron James Moore (1762–99) around 1794–95. Indeed, there is something about the insecure perspective displayed here, which represents the not-so-high choir extending at an excessive length to an over-dominant tower, that recalls Girtin’s view Louth Church (TG1029), of around 1795–96, and an awareness of such shortcomings might explain why the artist did not realise the composition as anything more substantial.

The drawing has been attributed in the past to Girtin’s contemporary Joseph Mallord William Turner (1775–1851), who also seems to have visited St Albans at roughly this date. The attribution to Girtin feels secure, however, even though the drawing’s weaknesses cannot help but make me wonder whether, rather than being an on-the-spot drawing, this was not another case of the artist copying a sketch from a secondary source. In other words, is the fact that Girtin came to St Albans to sketch around 1796 colouring our judgement about a drawing that, in comparison with views such as St Albans Abbey: The West Porch, seems less assured? Searching through the views of St Albans made by the significant number of artists who visited this location, which was close enough to London to be reached on a day trip, has not yet turned up any candidates for Girtin’s source, however. Moreover, I have not entirely ruled out the possibility that the drawing, although surely by Girtin, might have actually been worked over an on-the-spot sketch made by Moore on one of his numerous antiquarian tours, as in the case of a number of views of churches in Sussex, such as The West Tower, All Saints’ Church, Hastings (TG0227). The manner in which a set of faint lines seem to have been enhanced by sharper, more assured touches, combined with the weak perspective, which leaves whole areas unresolved, suggests that this might be a possibility, though working from a photograph makes this difficult to confirm.

The drawing’s provenance has also been the subject of some confusion (Exhibitions: Birmingham, 1939, no.194a), but this seems to have been sorted out by Paul Oppé (1878–1957), who bought the work for the National Gallery of Canada in 1953. The details given here follow those that Oppé passed on to Thomas Girtin (1874–1960), which are noted in the Girtin Archive (29).

(?) 1796

The Gateway, St Albans Abbey

TG1034

(?) 1796

St Albans Abbey: The West Porch

TG1035

1796

The Interior of St Albans Abbey

TG1040

1795 - 1796

Louth Church

TG1029

1795

The West Tower, All Saints’ Church, Hastings

TG0227