1795 - 1796
A Riverside Cottage, Said to Be a Watermill
TG1435
- Description
-
- Creator(s)
- (?) Thomas Girtin (1775-1802)
- Title
-
- A Farm with an Unidentified Windmill
- Date
- 1795 - 1796
- Medium and Support
- Graphite and watercolour on paper
- Dimensions
- 18 × 19.5 cm, 7 ⅛ × 7 ¾ in
- Object Type
- Studio Watercolour
- Subject Terms
- Essex View; Picturesque Vernacular; Wind and Water Mills
-
- Collection
- Catalogue Number
- TG1417
- Description Source(s)
- Auction Catalogue
Provenance
The Red Cross sale, Christie's, unknown date, lot 31; ... A. M. Mason; his sale, Sotheby's, 15 July 1976, lot 74 as 'The Mill' by Joseph Mallord William Turner, £1,700
Place depicted
Other entries in London and the Home Counties, Together with Miscellaneous Studies and Views
Thomas Girtin
Windsor Castle, from the River Thames
Windsor Castle, from the River Thames
Harvard Art Museums / Fogg Museum
Thomas Girtin
Great Bookham Church, from the East
Great Bookham Church, from the East
Private Collection, Norfolk
Thomas Girtin
Windsor Park and Castle, from Snow Hill
Windsor Park and Castle, from Snow Hill
Anglesey Abbey, Cambridgeshire (National Trust)
Thomas Girtin
The Gateway, St Albans Abbey
The Gateway, St Albans Abbey
Ashmolean Museum, University of Oxford
Thomas Girtin
St Albans Abbey: The West Porch
St Albans Abbey: The West Porch
Yale Center for British Art, New Haven
Thomas Girtin
St Albans Abbey: The West Porch
St Albans Abbey: The West Porch
Yale Center for British Art, New Haven
Thomas Girtin
St Albans Abbey, from the East
St Albans Abbey, from the East
National Gallery of Canada, Ottawa
Thomas Girtin, Edward Dayes
An Interior View of St Albans Abbey, from the Crossing
An Interior View of St Albans Abbey, from the Crossing
Art Gallery of South Australia, Adelaide
Thomas Girtin
The Interior of St Albans Abbey
The Interior of St Albans Abbey
Blackburn Museum and Art Gallery
Thomas Girtin
Windsor Castle and the Great Park, from the South West
Windsor Castle and the Great Park, from the South West
Private Collection, Norfolk
Thomas Girtin, Samuel Howitt
Windsor Great Park: Herne’s Oak with a Herd of Deer
Windsor Great Park: Herne’s Oak with a Herd of Deer
Yale Center for British Art, New Haven
Thomas Girtin, Samuel Howitt
Stags Fighting amongst a Herd of Deer in Windsor Great Park, with the Castle in the Distance
Stags Fighting amongst a Herd of Deer in Windsor Great Park, with the Castle in the Distance
Private Collection
Thomas Girtin, Samuel Howitt
A Herd of Deer in Richmond Park
A Herd of Deer in Richmond Park
Private Collection
Thomas Girtin
A Panoramic View of the Thames from the Adelphi Terrace, Section One: Somerset House to Blackfriars Bridge
A Panoramic View of the Thames from the Adelphi Terrace, Section One: Somerset House to Blackfriars Bridge
Private Collection
Thomas Girtin
A Panoramic View of the Thames from the Adelphi Terrace, Section Two: The Surrey Bank
A Panoramic View of the Thames from the Adelphi Terrace, Section Two: The Surrey Bank
Private Collection
Thomas Girtin
A Panoramic View of the Thames from the Adelphi Terrace, Section Three: Westminster Bridge to York Stairs
A Panoramic View of the Thames from the Adelphi Terrace, Section Three: Westminster Bridge to York Stairs
Private Collection
Thomas Girtin
Westminster, from the West Corner of the Adelphi Terrace
Westminster, from the West Corner of the Adelphi Terrace
Private Collection
Thomas Girtin, Margaretta Elizabeth Perceval (née Wilson), Lady Arden
The Thames with St Paul's and Blackfriars Bridge
The Thames with St Paul's and Blackfriars Bridge
The Morgan Library & Museum
Thomas Girtin
Shipping on the Thames, Looking down Limehouse Reach towards Greenwich, with the Church of St Alfege in the Distance
Shipping on the Thames, Looking down Limehouse Reach towards Greenwich, with the Church of St Alfege in the Distance
Private Collection
Thomas Girtin
A Haystack on a Farm, on the Road to Harrow-on-the-Hill
A Haystack on a Farm, on the Road to Harrow-on-the-Hill
Private Collection
Thomas Girtin
A Panoramic Landscape, near Norwood
A Panoramic Landscape, near Norwood
Private Collection
Thomas Girtin
St James’s Park, with Westminster Abbey in the Distance
St James’s Park, with Westminster Abbey in the Distance
National Gallery of Art, Washington
Thomas Girtin
St Paul’s Cathedral, from St Martin’s-le-Grand
St Paul’s Cathedral, from St Martin’s-le-Grand
Yale Center for British Art, New Haven
Thomas Girtin
St Paul's Cathedral, from St Martin’s-le-Grand
St Paul's Cathedral, from St Martin’s-le-Grand
Untraced Works
Thomas Girtin
St Paul’s Cathedral, from St Martin’s-le-Grand
St Paul’s Cathedral, from St Martin’s-le-Grand
Private Collection
Thomas Girtin
St Paul’s Cathedral, from St Martin’s-le-Grand
St Paul’s Cathedral, from St Martin’s-le-Grand
Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York
Unknown Artist
A River Scene, with Boats
A River Scene, with Boats
Victoria and Albert Museum, London
Thomas Girtin
An Imaginary Coast Scene with the Horizontal Air Mill at Battersea
An Imaginary Coast Scene with the Horizontal Air Mill at Battersea
Private Collection
Thomas Girtin
London: The Leathersellers’ Hall
London: The Leathersellers’ Hall
British Museum, London
Thomas Girtin
London: The Interior of the Ruins of the Leathersellers’ Hall
London: The Interior of the Ruins of the Leathersellers’ Hall
British Museum, London
Thomas Girtin
Pinckney’s Farm, Radwinter
Pinckney’s Farm, Radwinter
Victoria and Albert Museum, London
Thomas Girtin
A Farm with an Unidentified Windmill
A Farm with an Unidentified Windmill
Private Collection
Thomas Girtin
Barns and a Pond, Said to Be near Bromley
Barns and a Pond, Said to Be near Bromley
Rhode Island School of Design Museum, Providence
Thomas Girtin
Barns and a Pond, Said to Be near Bromley
Barns and a Pond, Said to Be near Bromley
Private Collection, Norfolk
Thomas Girtin
Trees and Pond, Said to Be near Bromley
Trees and Pond, Said to Be near Bromley
Yale Center for British Art, New Haven
Thomas Girtin
A Sandpit, near Logs Hill, Widmore
A Sandpit, near Logs Hill, Widmore
Private Collection
Thomas Girtin
A Sandpit, near Logs Hill, Widmore
A Sandpit, near Logs Hill, Widmore
Private Collection
Thomas Girtin
The Church of St Mary the Virgin, Stone-next-Dartford
The Church of St Mary the Virgin, Stone-next-Dartford
British Museum, London
Thomas Girtin
A Farmhouse in a Woodland Setting, Said to Be in Devon
A Farmhouse in a Woodland Setting, Said to Be in Devon
Yale Center for British Art, New Haven
Thomas Girtin
Farm Buildings, Probably in Surrey
Farm Buildings, Probably in Surrey
The Whitworth, University of Manchester
John Sell Cotman
Tintern Village, Seen across the Forge Pond, Formerly Known as ‘The Mill-Pond’
Tintern Village, Seen across the Forge Pond, Formerly Known as ‘The Mill-Pond’
Private Collection
Thomas Girtin
A Picturesque House Overlooking a River, with Distant Windmills
A Picturesque House Overlooking a River, with Distant Windmills
Sidney and Lois Eskenazi Museum of Art, Indiana University, Bloomington
Thomas Girtin
The West End of an Unidentified Church
The West End of an Unidentified Church
Private Collection
Thomas Girtin
An Unidentified Windmill, Probably in Lambeth
An Unidentified Windmill, Probably in Lambeth
Sarah Campbell Blaffer Foundation, Houston
Thomas Girtin
Unidentified Buildings, Herne Hill
Unidentified Buildings, Herne Hill
The Huntington Library, Art Museum and Botanical Gardens, San Marino
Thomas Girtin
Study of a Sailor on Board a Ship; A Fishing Boat
Study of a Sailor on Board a Ship; A Fishing Boat
Private Collection
Thomas Girtin
The Frozen Watermill, from William Cowper's The Task
The Frozen Watermill, from William Cowper's The Task
The Huntington Library, Art Museum and Botanical Gardens, San Marino
Thomas Girtin
An Unidentified Subject, Probably from James Macpherson’s Poems of Ossian
An Unidentified Subject, Probably from James Macpherson’s Poems of Ossian
Tate, London
Thomas Girtin
The Eruption of Mount Vesuvius
The Eruption of Mount Vesuvius
The Morgan Library & Museum
Thomas Girtin
The Archangel Gabriel Awaiting Night, from John Milton's Paradise Lost
The Archangel Gabriel Awaiting Night, from John Milton's Paradise Lost
Yale Center for British Art, New Haven
Thomas Girtin
Portrait Study of a Man, Said to Be the Artist George Barret the Younger
Portrait Study of a Man, Said to Be the Artist George Barret the Younger
Private Collection
Thomas Girtin
A Study of a Lion from the Tower of London
A Study of a Lion from the Tower of London
Private Collection
Thomas Girtin
An Open Field with a Cart and Horses, Known as ‘The Carter’
An Open Field with a Cart and Horses, Known as ‘The Carter’
British Museum, London
Thomas Girtin
A Church Seen across Fields, with Another Sketch Depicting a Woman
A Church Seen across Fields, with Another Sketch Depicting a Woman
The Huntington Library, Art Museum and Botanical Gardens, San Marino
Thomas Girtin
A Landscape with Figures by Railings
A Landscape with Figures by Railings
Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco
Thomas Girtin
Self-Portrait of the Artist at Work
Self-Portrait of the Artist at Work
British Museum, London
William Pearson
An Unidentified Landscape, with a Church amongst Trees
An Unidentified Landscape, with a Church amongst Trees
Yale Center for British Art, New Haven
Thomas Girtin
A Cottage and a Windmill Surrounded by Trees
A Cottage and a Windmill Surrounded by Trees
Private Collection
Thomas Girtin
St Paul’s Cathedral, from the Thames
St Paul’s Cathedral, from the Thames
Private Collection
Thomas Girtin
Old London Bridge, with the Shot Tower in Construction, and St Olave's Church
Old London Bridge, with the Shot Tower in Construction, and St Olave's Church
Private Collection
Revisions & Feedback
The website will be updated from time to time and, when changes are made, a PDF of the previous version of each page will be archived here for consultation and citation.
Please help us to improve this catalogue
If you have information, a correction or any other suggestions to improve this catalogue, please contact us.
About this Work
This view of a mill and farm buildings is known only from a black and white photograph taken when the watercolour was last seen in public, on the occasion that it appeared at auction in 1976 as by Joseph Mallord William Turner (1775–1851). The attribution certainly made sense, since the work depicts the same group of buildings seen in another watercolour by Turner that appeared on the art market in 2013 (see figure 1) and that appears to be an autograph work by the artist from about 1794. However, the slightly smaller view under consideration here differs considerably in its details from Turner’s watercolour, though, in turn, it accords with another view of the same farm and mill that is titled ‘Landscape, Possibly Blackwater Estuary’, presumably referring to the site in Essex (see figure 2). This has hitherto only been known from a poor-quality black and white image in the Witt Library where the watercolour was attributed to Girtin. This more recent colour image, made when the drawing was with the Martyn Gregory Gallery, came with an attribution to Turner, but it is sadly not good enough to confirm the merits of the change of attribution from Girtin. Working from two poor images, it is therefore not possible to say any more at this stage than that at least one of the mill compositions might be by Girtin and that, if the building was located on the Blackwater Estuary, the artist would have had to work from a sketch by someone else. This likewise goes for Turner, who is not known to have visited the area either. The composition bears a striking similarity to another picturesque mill scene, A Riverside Cottage (TG1435) that was based on a print after a watercolour by Thomas Hearne (1744–1817) and I suspect that a secondary source might yet be found for this drawing too, though that would not necessarily help with its attribution.